| Author | Message |
|---|---|
Search found 12 matches |
|
| Posted: | Wed Jul 27, 2005 8:21 pm |
| Forum: | Personae |
| Subject: | Severus Snape: Dumbledore's Man Through and Through |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 18 Views: 58122 |
I like your theory and would readily agree with it but…a poster on another forum is stating that Dumbledore would never under any circumstances condone the use of AK, I am awaiting citations to suppo ... |
| Posted: | Sun Jul 24, 2005 7:32 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | The Death of Emmeline Vance |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 14 Views: 15114 |
To add my two knuts worth to this thread I will weigh in with the following thoughts.
Addressing the comments made by Snape in Spinner’s End about her death, I think it important to consider the f ... |
| Posted: | Sun Jul 24, 2005 6:52 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | Does it really matter? |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 27 Views: 27402 |
I feel that I should clarify my post a little.
I did not mean to use the movies as canon. I was just trying to point out a seeming incongruity. The reason I used the movie is that although Ho ... |
| Posted: | Sun Jul 24, 2005 5:38 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
I can't remember, and I don't have the books handy at the moment, but would Fawkes' tears antidote any poison? If so, why would Dumbledore not call Fawkes to him, at the very latest when he returned ... |
| Posted: | Sat Jul 23, 2005 10:33 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
I thought that Dumbledore whitened because of what Harry learned. Dumbledore has consistently refused to tell Harry why he trusts Snape. I think that Harry is coming far too close to the truth for ... |
| Posted: | Sat Jul 23, 2005 9:49 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
Please don´t be angry with me, but I madly deeply truely hope you are wrong in this point!!!
Gosh, I hope I am, too! Although I would rather have him die a Good!Snape than live (or die) an Evil!Sn ... |
| Posted: | Sat Jul 23, 2005 7:05 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
Responding to both previous post,
I am not yet sure if the "act" was in his past, I sure hope it was and that JK is carefully trying to keep people from being to able to argue and convince others ... |
| Posted: | Sat Jul 23, 2005 3:28 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
JK just delivered what seems a devastating blow to my Snape is not evil theory….
MA: Oh, here’s one [from our forums] that I’ve really got to ask you. Has Snape ever been loved by anyone? JKR: ... |
| Posted: | Sat Jul 23, 2005 12:58 am |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | Does it really matter? |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 27 Views: 27402 |
What is so fascinating about Severus Snape?
For me it is not just one or two things but the whole complexity of his character, both what is in the books and movies but what JK says in her intervie ... |
| Posted: | Fri Jul 22, 2005 9:43 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
Dumbledore (unless he was lying) tells Draco that he's known all year that Draco was trying to kill him. That fact doesn't fit with this (otherwise quite nice and very plausible) theory. Aye! ... |
| Posted: | Fri Jul 22, 2005 5:24 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | My Why-Snape-Is-Not-Evil Theory (Spoilers) |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 112 Views: 2170323 |
Theory for Snape being good
Why did no one teach Harry Occlumency? After all importance placed upon his learning it in OotP even in the end…none is placed upon it in HBP tell the end when Snape ... |
| Posted: | Fri Jul 22, 2005 5:21 pm |
| Forum: | The Library |
| Subject: | Spinner's End |
| EnigmaVX Replies: 9 Views: 37011 |
Starting with Unbreakable Vow I think the title of the chapter is very telling, Spinner’s End perhaps reference to a spider or one who spins things… first reflections says Snape as the Spinner since ... |
All times are GMT
|
Page 1 of 1
|
|---|
Powered by phpBB
//
Template by Mike Lothar